Most people accept the first number they're given. Every dollar you leave on the table at offer stage compounds for the rest of your career — it's the base for every future raise, every next offer. Here's how to negotiate, with the exact scripts to use.
Quick Facts
Walking into a salary conversation without data is the most expensive preparation mistake in a job search. You need three numbers before the negotiation call:
Canadian salary data is thinner than US data on most platforms. For roles at Canadian companies, LinkedIn Salary filtered to the specific city is more reliable than Levels.fyi, which skews heavily US. For Canadian banks (CIBC, RBC, TD, BMO, Scotiabank), internal pay bands are tight — negotiating 5–10% above the offer is realistic; 20%+ is unlikely.
Do not negotiate during the interview process. Compensation questions early signal you're more focused on pay than the role — which hurts your leverage. The right time is after you've received a verbal or written offer.
When you receive the offer, do not accept or negotiate on the spot. Say:
"Thank you so much — I'm genuinely excited about this opportunity. I'd like to take 24 hours to review the full package and come back to you. Is that okay?"
This is not stalling — it's professional. Use those 24 hours to verify your market data, confirm your numbers, and prepare your script.
Negotiate by phone or video, not email. A confident voice is harder to dismiss than a message. Call back within the agreed window. Structure your call in three parts:
"Hi [name] — thank you again for the offer. I've had a chance to review everything and I'm very excited about the role and the team. I'd love to make this work."
"Based on my research using Levels.fyi and LinkedIn Salary for [role] in [city], and considering [X years of experience / specific skill / competing offer if applicable], I was expecting something closer to $[anchor number]. Is there flexibility to get there?"
Then stop talking. The silence after "Is there flexibility?" is important. The first person to speak after the ask is at a disadvantage. Wait for their response.
Express genuine enthusiasm. Ask for the revised offer in writing. Do not add new requests — you've won.
Counter once toward your target, or accept and negotiate other terms (signing bonus, review date, equity). Don't leave the call without asking about the full package.
Ask about non-salary alternatives (below). If the total package is below your walk-away number after exhausting options, that's your answer — not a failure.
Some companies — especially larger organizations with rigid pay bands — genuinely cannot move on base salary. This is not the end of the negotiation. Base salary is one line item. The full package has many:
"I understand — I appreciate you checking. Given that base is set, is there any flexibility on a signing bonus to help bridge the gap? Or could we build in a 6-month salary review so we have a natural checkpoint to revisit this?"
A competing offer is the strongest negotiating lever you have. But use it only if it's real — fabricating one is both unethical and a serious risk if the employer calls your bluff.
If you have a genuine competing offer:
"I want to be transparent — I do have another offer at $[X]. This role is genuinely my first choice, and I'd love to find a way to make the numbers work. Is there any flexibility to get closer to that?"
Naming the number from the competing offer creates a concrete anchor. The framing of "first choice" makes clear you want to accept their offer — you're giving them the chance to win you, not threatening to leave.
Never give an ultimatum unless you're prepared to walk. "I need this number or I'll decline" is a closing move, not an opening one. Use it only after you've exhausted all flexibility — and only if you mean it.
Interview Intel's compensation playbook benchmarks your role at your specific company — so you walk in with data, not a guess. Free preview, full report for $20.
Get your compensation benchmark →Is it okay to negotiate salary after receiving a job offer?
Yes. Over 70% of hiring managers have room to negotiate. Accepting the first offer without asking leaves money on the table in most cases. The worst they can say is no — which puts you exactly where you started.
How do I negotiate without losing the offer?
Negotiate by phone. Open with enthusiasm for the role. Name your number with a market-data justification. Then stop talking. Offers are almost never rescinded because a candidate politely negotiated — it would be an unusual hiring manager who rescinded for asking once.
What if they say the salary is non-negotiable?
Negotiate everything else: signing bonus, 6-month performance review, remote work flexibility, extra vacation, equity, or professional development budget. Base salary is one line item in the full package.
Preparing for your interview?
Get free Interview Intel preview →